I'm thinking about suing someone. Need Advice
So I bought a house. We gave them a 2-month rent back (we PAID THEIR RENT to live in it, this was our way to sweeten the deal to win it). But it's our house when they were living in it. They are essentially renters.
A few weeks before we are to move-in, I swing by to measure a room and I notice the carpets are destroyed. There are pet stains on the landing and the edge of the steps are all chewed up and frayed. Obviously, it didn't look like this when we bought it: not a single agent mentioned damaged carpets, my wife would have noticed, 4 people all placed on offer on this house and NO ONE mentioned the carpets. They mentioned that their dog had to be put down, so my guess is the dog lost control in the last days of its life.
We asked them to replace the carpets, they refused, said they would "repair" them.
Well, it's better, but no.
So what do you think? They cost $1,500 to replace, it's just on the stairs. Do I have a case in small claims court? Have you done this before?
Attached are some pictures: ONE of the steps before they "repaired" it. And the remaining 3 are after their "repair". I didn't attach it here, but we amazingly have a before picture of it all looking perfect. And we have a pic of a bad pet stain on the landing. What do you think?